Knox College
Class of 1972
David Butler's sermon at Central Congregational
Sermon. Central Congregational of Galesburg. October 23, 2022
Psalm 131 *, John 21:15-19 **
It is an honor to be asked to do this today. To quote Guy Clark, this is pretty high cotton for me. I thank the committee for the opportunity to do this.
I retired from full time work in the church ten years ago now. We moved from our small town in northern Wisconsin to a farm in the center of the state. And I have no intention of spending much time making my classmates who are still working or those of you who are younger and still out there feel bad about being gainfully employed, but I will just say this: if I had known it was going to be this much fun, I never would have worked a day in my life.
But don’t be deceived: this time of life is no cake walk. We’re still too young to dress alike and play golf. And we are finding that the real definition of retired is “to be tired again.”
But the class of 1972 is ironically at or near the age of 72. And perhaps it’s a time we took a reflective moment around some of this.
I have tried to think about what to call this. Unless we intend to live to the age of 144, that middle age thing is off the table. For a long time I went with “brand new old guy”. But that seems to have worn off. But I finally think I have settled on what I want to call this time of my life. I have chosen to call them my declining years.
I received a letter last year from a member of our regional committee in charge of recruiting people, asking me to be on a committee I was on as a young man, and one that bored me to death when I did it. It was with deep satisfaction and pleasure that I declined. I’m too old to do stuff I don’t want to do anymore; hence, my declining years.
And I just have one more thing to say about retirement and see if you’ll back me up on this. There are two things I find that every single retired person, regardless of their vocation or employment or field of endeavor will agree upon. It doesn’t matter what you did, I expect you believe these two things. One is that we got out of there in the nick of time, because it’s about to get complicated. Yes? The other is that now that the bullets have stopped flying and I can stand up straight and can really look around, I know what’s really wrong with this outfit.
It is in this spirit that I chose the passages that are before us this morning. And I believe I will speak about the psalm first, psalm 131.
Did this psalm sound strange to you? It does to me. So unlike so many others, that either pontificate on the greatness of things: the heavens are telling the glory of God! Or the horror of things: I am persecuted and despised: God, dash my enemy’s children against the rocks!
The psalm is so tiny, so intimate, so close in. I love it because it feels more like my life than any of the others. My soul is content, like a weaned child in my arms. It hits a grandfather where he lives.
In his commentary on this psalm, Eugene Peterson describes it as a maintenance psalm; a pruning psalm. And he talks about the counterintuitive practice of trimming plants so that they will grow. Two things get pruned from us in the embracing of this psalm, he says. They are unruly ambition and infantile dependency.
We have in this room this morning perhaps the densest concentration of high achievers that is to be found in the Midwest, at 11:00 on a Sunday morning. You have accomplished amazing things in your life. I am humbled to be considered your friend and colleague. And it is quite possible that we have Knox College to thank for much of that. I believe that I got into seminary just because I went here. They couldn’t possibly have looked at my grade point average. (My grandmother called my degree “magna cum ordinary.”) And I don’t know what your experience was of post graduate education, but I will say to you that seminary was easier than this.
David Brooks, the New York Times columnist, in a graduation address he gave once, decried the old graduation bromide of following your dreams. He said, most of us, when we are graduating don’t have dreams. We have fears, and we have things that annoy us. And he said, most of us, if we even get to choose a field of endeavor, go out with the intention of fixing the things that annoy us.
I think I went into my field pretty well pruned to start with. Maybe you did too. I didn’t have anything resembling ambition. I was just pleased that someone let me in. I was perhaps more guilty of a form of infantile dependency, but the David Brooks factor was alive in me as well. There was lots about the church that annoyed me, although I really knew very little about it.
But my field, and perhaps your field, is doggedly and insidiously designed to foster unruly ambition and infantile dependency. The ministers that I have respected the most in my career came into this like Jesus in John, chapter 13. They just wanted to wash some feet. The ones for whom I had the least respect wanted to save the world. And yet we all fell victim to the symbol of ego and self-aggrandizement: the pedestal. The more we get pushed up, the more we get pushed away. And healthy aspiration turns to unhealthy ambition. And it may be that simple obedience turns to immature dependency. And too often, that resulted in a crippling loneliness that took many of us down.
Enter here the gospel. You probably thought I forgot it. No. This is just how I do. The scene begins with the disciples of Jesus having had the roller coaster day of their lives. They have been told by Mary Magdalene, called by some the apostle to the apostles, that the outcome of the earlier horror was different than they supposed. Their Lord had risen. They experienced elation. Then they realized that they were probably in more danger than they had thought, and they were afraid. Then, finally, they were just lost. They didn’t know what any of this meant and didn’t know how to find out. So Peter, their leader, threw up his hands and said, “I’m going fishing.” And to be honest, that’s what I would have done. And they fished all night and caught nothing. That too is what I would have done. They don’t call it catching, after all. It’s fishing. And then this is what happened. (read John 21:15-19)
I took Greek and Hebrew in seminary. They didn’t give you enough to get good at it, just enough to frustrate you. My second day in Greek class, the professor asked if anyone could write the Greek alphabet on the board. My hand flew up and I jumped up and wrote “alpha, beta, gamma, delta…” When I sat back down, the woman next to me leaned over and in a sardonic whisper asked, “what fraternity were you in?” I said, “three times on a match, baby…” It was the last time I raised my hand in Greek class.
So at this point, I only know enough Greek to look up words and maybe read it out loud without understanding. But I did learn enough to find something remarkable in this story.
The Greeks had something like eight different words for love. Love for them was like snow to an Athabascan. Not like us. The three that predominate are eros, filia and agape. Eros is passion, and all that that implies. Filia is fellowship, sibling affection, family ties that bind, the love I feel for the friends I have gathered through my life. Agape, however, is very different. It is loving the way God loves. It is the love you are given every day, like a weaned child in parental arms. It has nothing to do with your personality or accomplishment or distinction or even your loveability. It was the love that was here waiting for you when you got here. It is, unlike the others, love that will not let you go.
Jesus asked Peter three times if he loved him. The first readers and hearers of these stories, quite possibly members of John’s congregation, would have heard the Greek. In the first question Jesus asks, Peter, do you agape me? And Peter responds, yes Lord, I filia you. Hmmm. Seemingly unsatisfied with that answer, Jesus asks again, Peter, do you agape me? And again Peter says, yes Lord, I filia you.
Now, I have never read any biblical commentary that has even noticed this, so here is what I think. There are people who study and write about faith development; in other words, what happens to you as you grow deeper in your faith walk, what happens when you are shallow or new in your faith walk, what are the characteristics of this stage of faith and that. And it’s interesting to read these things because you can always tell where you are. As soon as you are reading out past where you are, you suddenly don’t know what they are talking about.
One such author might describe Peter’s faith as an affiliative faith. In other words, his faith is in the group. It’s in the affiliation. It’s the kind of faith I saw in many of my high school kids when I was a youth pastor. Their faith was in the group and what we did in the group. I suspect that Peter didn’t get agape love and only gave what he had. And credit him, at least he was honest.
And so in the third question: Jesus does this. He asks, Peter, do you filia me? And as you heard, Peter responded you know everything. Of course I do. And here is what makes room for me in this story. Despite the inadequacy of Peter’s answer, despite his repeated failures throughout the whole story, Jesus still has work for him to do. Feed my sheep. Tend my lambs.
Then comes this ominous prediction. You used to walk around and do what you want. You chose which classes to take, sat in the Gizmo with whomever you wanted to, you walked around free. But once old, you would be bound and taken where you don’t want to go.
I think the early Christians hearing this would have heard in here the cost of discipleship. You will be persecuted for your faith. Peter would also spread his arms and be crucified as Jesus was. They would hear that their joy in the faith would be tempered with sacrifice.
Although few of us have escaped the experience of sacrifice, I suspect, and even suffering, I believe we might be invited to hear something a little different. You don’t get nailed to a tree around here for being obedient very much. And yet these words seem hauntingly close to home.
Or as one of my mentors used to say to me, so what?
Richard Rohr, the Franciscan monk, wrote a book some time ago entitled Falling Upward. In there he describes the two phases of life. In the first, we build our container and fill it up with our lives. We find, he says, quoting Archimedes, a lever and a place to stand. We fill up our container with accomplishments and relationships and expertise and possessions. The second half of life is like moving out of the big house and into the condo: it’s spent sorting through what we have gathered, trying to understand what it is we have put together, and what no longer needs to go with us. What can we get rid of, what don’t we need any more, what no longer fits with what it seems our lives have come to mean.
I can look at any one day of my life and it can look like a jailbreak: things flying here and there. But if I look at my life as if I were walking on a beach, dragging a stick in the sand, I can look back and see a pattern. I can see that I needed to endure this failure here so that I would better appreciate this success over here. I would endure this heartache here so that I could more fully savor this delight over here. And I look at it all, and I no longer see a random jumble of disconnected events, but a journey quite guided, I feel, by a power greater than myself who seemingly loves me more than I need.
And again, so what? This has been long, but I hope you’ll forgive me. I’ve been thinking about all this for a long time. So I guess this. I thank Knox College for being my lever. I don’t think I found my place to stand until later, but this was my lever. You were my lever. I can honestly say that I have never been in the company of a more remarkable community of people than I was here. It took me many years, and a scolding wife to learn to appreciate just hanging out with normal people.
And then I would end with this. As I root around in my container, making sense out of all that has happened, despite the fact that so often now I am not the master of my fate, but called to service of one kind or another, I am truly grateful for a rich and fruitful life. I have a life that means something to me. I am free to rid myself of unruly ambition and infantile dependency and pedestals and to live into what Erik Erikson called a time of generativity, where we plant trees we won’t see grow. It’s okay to find peace in an awful world, because the world has always been awful, and God has always wished us peace. I pray that for me and I pray that for you, from a grateful heart. We will be better people in a chaotic world if we can embrace this. May God continue to bless and use us all. Amen.
* Psalms 131
1 A Song of Ascents. Of David. Lord, my heart is not haughty, Nor my eyes lofty. Neither do I concern myself with great matters, Nor with things too profound for me.
2 Surely I have calmed and quieted my soul, Like a weaned child with his mother; Like a weaned child is my soul within me.
3 O Israel, hope in the Lord From this time forth and forever.
** John 21:15-19
15 So when they had eaten breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of Jonah, do you love Me more than these?" He said to Him, "Yes, Lord; You know that I love You." He said to him, "Feed My lambs."
16 He said to him again a second time, "Simon, son of Jonah, do you love Me?" He said to Him, "Yes, Lord; You know that I love You." He said to him, "Tend My sheep."
17 He said to him the third time, "Simon, son of Jonah, do you love Me?" Peter was grieved because He said to him the third time, "Do you love Me?" And he said to Him, "Lord, You know all things; You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My sheep."
18 Most assuredly, I say to you, when you were younger, you girded yourself and walked where you wished; but when you are old, you will stretch out your hands, and another will gird you and carry you where you do not wish."
19 This He spoke, signifying by what death he would glorify God. And when He had spoken this, He said to him, "Follow Me."